Tuesday 24 September 2013

KEMU vs AIMC!

The choice between King Edward Medical University and Allama Iqbal Medical College is not as easy as it seems. Most people will advice you to blind fold yourself and choose the prestige and name of KEMU. But is prestige enough to commit the most important five years of your life? So lets discuss the pros and cons of either of both the universities before making a decision.

Pros of joining KEMU
  • It is an independent degree awarding university and so you'll have a distinct certificate compared to the ones affiliated to UHS or Punjab University. This could be considered as a con too with the internal examinations of KEMU still having an age old pattern with long essay questions that are no more found in UHS exams.
  • The alumni body. KEMU has a huge network of alumni that is spread all over the world. KEMCANA (King Edward Medical College Alumni Association of North America) along with KEMCA UK are very strong alumni bodies of colleges that'll help you reach your dream goals.
  • The prestige. Obviously, it matters. It has been over 125 since the stones of the college were laid down. The history is quite mesmerizing and this is one reason why so many people prefer this college over any other. And name is mainly because it is at the top of the merit list. 
  • The clinical experience of government universities is always a plus point and Mayo Hospital is among the largest ones in Asia so that could be an alluring factor. But there isn't much difference in clinical teaching from AIMC as Jinnah Hospital is equally good, infact the latter is better maintained. 
  • The male hostels are definitely better than the hostels of AIMC.
  • There are plenty of cadavers to get hands on experience of dissection. You'll never have a problem getting your hands on a bone or any organ of the body while other universities don't have such a surplus.
  • There is a rumor going on that KEMU is shifting its curriculum towards a modular basis. The one like in the universities of Karachi including Dow and AKU. This will make KEMU the first one in Punjab to employ such methods and will definitely make it your best choice. But this is not confirmed yet so you better keep your fingers crossed.

Cons of joining KEMU
  • The teaching methodology is out dated. They still have long essay questions in their examinations and the teachers are not really the best around with some exceptions of course. But this is a problem in all government universities so you can't really blame KE alone. 
  • The building has existed way beyond its expiry date. And apart from the administrative building, the whole university is on the verge of collapsing. Yes, there is some exaggeration in that but seriously the benches in lecture halls need to be repaired. With the whole class present in the lecture room, ten percent of the students have to sit on the stairs. The dissection hall is pretty dark, the Biochemistry lab is outdated and only the Histology lab is well maintained and something that makes KE students proud of it. The grounds are well maintained but there are not enough of them.
  • The environment of KEMU is pretty conservative when it comes to opposite gender interaction. Most of the government universities are the same in this regard but KE's policy of separating the roll numbers of guys and girls and having separate demonstration is a representation of extreme conservatism. But this could be included in pros too.
  • Girls hostel is in a pathetic state. At the beginning of the year the girls would regret coming to KE as they will only get the space enough to have a mattress. If you are from Lahore then well enough but otherwise, get ready for some hefty fights at the beginning of your medical education.

Pros of joining AIMC
  • First of all, the building is extremely better as compared to KEMU's. Different departments have separate buildings that are well spaced out. The dissection and lecture halls are pretty well maintained. And there are more opportunities for boys who play sports with better grounds and facilities.
  • AIMC is affiliated to UHS so it has a much better examination pattern with a better curriculum. Plus, you get the degree of UHS which is ranked second in the HEC rankings for health universities. 
  • The conservative environment is less expressed here as there is no segregation of roll numbers. 
  • The alumni body is still growing but it is quite strong especially in North America with its alumni body: AAPNA.

I'm sure those with high merits will now be in a conundrum of making the right choice. The next five years are the most important of your life and you will have to decide for yourself what is more important for you. Make sure your parents or friends don't alter your decision as it is you who has to live the life. Best of luck! :)


28 comments:

  1. what do u think about the merit now? does anyone above 89 percent aggregate will be selected for aimc?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Above or below 89? I think the lowest aggregate for AIMC will almost be the same as last year.

    ReplyDelete
  3. So how is your time at KEMU? Do you wish that you would have joined AKU?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It could have been worse. Not a day goes by without this wish. :)

      Delete
    2. Stay Strong :P

      Delete
    3. Stay Strong because we need more unselfish people like you in this World. :P

      Delete
  4. Tell me one thing, does it really matter which Uni we choose to do MBBS from, even if its a private Uni with low Merit? because my friends and other people say its Masters that really matters. Kemu or Aimc or Aku, do they improve the masters degree somehow? :P

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Degree and education is same wherever we go. But the quality of education varies. In government universities, the faculty is too low! Like there are about 300 and 350 students selected each year for MBBS,say for example, in each government university. You can well guess it now what I am trying to say!

      Delete
  5. with reference to the conservative atmosphere, is it the same at the dental school? Demont

    ReplyDelete
  6. if I come from an a levels background, how far do you think I would b able to adjust to the conservative environment in govt. med colleges like k.e.? would a private school be a better option for me?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Please spare some time, are CMH and Shalamar both better than Shifa?? Which one should I join presuming I'll get admission in all three of them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Brother, I want to ask that if I get an admission at government college with the lowest merit (say for example at Nawaz sharif Gujrat). Is it a good idea to go for it? Or I should try other university like CMH or Al-shifa? Is it always a good idea to go for a public sector medical university no matters how much is the merit? If it is so...then what is the difference between King Edward and Nawaz sharif? (ofcourse both are government universities).

      Delete
    2. All the government universities have the same degree of UHS except for KEMU's. It's the name and teachers that makes the difference in the end. It has to be your choice, you are going to get the same degree in CMH too, but ofcourse you'll have to pay there much more. The studies and facilities would be better there, but in later years your training is definitely going to be better in a government hospital as compared to the private hospitals due to the difference in the patients. It has to be your own preference in the end.

      Delete
  8. Are you satisfied going to KEMU? The environment and everything, is it too much on us A level students? Should I.consider AKU? It's just that aga Khan os too expensive and I dont want to be a burden on my mother. Im confused, dont know what to do...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Aga Khan is the premier institution for modern medical education in Pakistan. Financial Aid packages and loans do cover the expenses at times.

      Delete
    2. The why didn't you go there. It's obvious you love AKU, but went to King Edward for some strange reason....no offence

      Delete
    3. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  9. Hey. I have an 89.55 merit and supposedly the merit will reduce this year so I'm hoping that maybe i have a chance at KE as well. But tell me, what should i mention as number 1 on my priority list? I want to give the usmle/mccee to move to N.America therefore graduating from which college would give me the better chance at acceptance? Does KE's name and prestige really make that much of a difference?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As I wrote above, there are perks of joining either KEMU or AIMC in their own way. Obviously, one feels really proud to tell people that they got into KE, and even if you choose to go to AIMC people will doubt that you had the merit to go higher. But the chances for USMLE are probably the same for both AIMC and KE. But I can tell you that a lot of people of KEMU go to US and UK every year after their graduation, which gives us a huge pool of alumni to contact and be with. You will find many seniors willing to guide you and help you. I'd suggest that you write King Edward as your first preference. :)

      Delete
  10. My aggregate amounts to 89.34 ,but i could get into KE on the basis of foreign seats,i've heard that AIMC's standard of education is better than KE's,but the latter is more prestigious,so my question is whether it is rational to compromise a good quality education for a good name?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Truly speaking, the quality of education is pretty similar in both institutions. It has to be completely your choice, I had the same dilemma and I ended up choosing the better name despite AIMC being very near to my home.

      Delete
    2. Ok,thanks.Do both the colleges have the same syllabi?

      Delete
    3. The syllabi are almost same, but the examination pattern is completely different as KE is a university itself, while AIMC is a constituent college of UHS and hence, the examination board is also the UHS.

      Delete
  11. what about the cons of aimc?

    ReplyDelete

Your suggestions and comments will be valued.